newyork1.jpg

SEC Continues Heavy Focus on Private Equity

The SEC is continuing to focus heavily on the private equity sector, reminding advisers in this space to be mindful of their practices. On May 13, 2015, Mark Wyatt, Acting Director, Office of Compliance Inspections and Examinations (“OCIE”) spoke to Private Equity International about the changes that have come and how OCIE anticipates going forward in the private equity arena. Much of Mr. Wyatt’s remarks reiterated the issues highlighted by Andrew Bowden, Director, Office of Compliance Inspections and Examinations, in his highly publicized speech on “Spreading Sunshine in Private Equity” last year.

Growth of the Private Equity Industry

Last year, Mr. Bowden mentioned in his remarks that “since the beginning of the millennium, the private equity industry’s assets under management…have increased year after year.  With the industry-wide portfolio value increasing steadily, and dry powder remaining around the $1 trillion mark, private equity assets under management are higher than they’ve ever been at just under $3.5 trillion as of June 30, 2013.”

According to Mr. Wyatt’s recent comments, “from year end 2011 through Q2 2014, the private equity industry grew by 25% …and capital raised by private equity firms increased by over 40% (from $354 billion in Q1 2012 to $503 billion in Q3 2014).” Mr. Wyatt also noted that “the size of funds that are currently being marketed has decreased by about 14% (from $410 million in January 2012 to $355 million in September 2014) suggesting that smaller managers are forming, contrary to industry concerns that the cost of SEC registration and regulation could stifle the formation of smaller managers. While the growth of the industry is a function of the free market, the business cycle, and the robust exit environment, it is not unreasonable to infer that greater transparency is fostering greater trust from investors and helping the industry to evolve and grow in healthy ways.”

SEC Focus Areas and Common Deficiencies Found in Private Equity

Mr. Wyatt’s speech focused on a recap of their activities in recent months and years as well as what improvements OCIE is looking to incorporate into their practices with respect to private equity advisers. OCIE has communicated to the public their observations from the 150 exams of private equity advisers completed in the last two years, with a focus on including the advisers’ collection of fees, allocation of expenses, marketing and valuation. OCIE found that, among other things, expense shifting and hidden fees where disclosure was limited or inadequate was common amongst these advisers. Mr. Wyatt reminded the audience that “advisers have an affirmative duty to fully and fairly describe “the deal” to investors, including discussing in a meaningful way how expenses will be assessed and fees will be collected.”

Misallocations of Expenses

As indicated above, by far the most common deficiencies found in private equity exams relate to expenses and expense allocation. The SEC has recently taken notable enforcement action against firms for participating in these questionable practices. Mr. Wyatt commented that “one of the most common and often cited practices in this area involves shifting expenses away from parallel funds created for insiders, friends, family, and preferred investors to the main co-mingled, flagship vehicles. Frequently, operational expenses, broken deal expenses, and even the formation expenses of the side-by-side vehicle are borne by investors in the main fund. Some of these expense items are small, but some, such as the broken deal expenses of an active fund, can be quite large. This practice can be a difficult one for investors to detect but easy for examiners to test.”

Co-Investment Allocations—The Need for Robust and Detailed Co-Investment Allocation Policies

Another area where OCIE has recently been dedicating resources is co-investment allocation. Over the past year, co-investments have become even more important to the industry.

Most of the observations by OCIE with respect to co-investments have been limited to policies and procedures, the Office has also detected several instances where investors in a fund were not aware that another investor negotiated priority co-investment rights. Disclosing this information is important because co-investment opportunities have a very real and tangible economic value but also can be a source of various conflicts of interest. Mr. Wyatt shared his concern that many private equity managers have responded to the SEC’s focus by disclosing less about the co-investment allocations rather than more under the theory that, if they do not promise anything, they will not be held accountable, However, Mr. Wyatt stressed the fact that promises to investors are nonetheless made over emails or orally, and they are not being disclosed. The solution, he said, is to adopt robust and detailed co-investment allocation policies shared with all investors. “All investors deserve to know where they stand in the co-investment priority stack”.

Real Estate Managers—Questionable Fee Practices

Mr. Wyatt added that OCIE is currently focusing on real estate managers in addition to traditional private equity. This is a new area of SEC focus. To our knowledge, real estate managers have not been singled out in an SEC speech before. Mr. Wyatt noted that real estate managers are more vertically integrated than traditional private equity managers. After buying a property, they offer property management, construction management and leasing for additional fees. They also charge back some of cost of their investment advisory employees and in-house attorneys. The SEC found that these fees are not always disclosed, and even when they are disclosed, managers promise investors that the additional services are “at market rates or below” which is frequently not the case.

More OCIE Exams and Enforcement Actions Coming Focusing on Private Equity

In speaking of the future, Mr. Wyatt said, “it is reasonable to assume that the next year may bring additional private equity actions by the SEC’s Division of Enforcement. Based on a recent speech titled “Conflicts, Conflicts Everywhere” by Julie Riewe, Co-Chief of the SEC Enforcement Division’s Asset Management Unit, we can expect additional enforcement actions involving undisclosed and misallocated fees and expenses as well as conflicts of interest. OCIE will also continue to vigilantly study and track the private capital markets and adjust their resources as necessary.

SEC3 can assist your firm in creating, implementing and maintaining your policies and procedures. For further information, please contact your SEC3 representative or contact us at This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it .

Newsletter

Get the latest compliance news and insights - delivered weekly. The SEC3 Communique covers all compliance topics. CCO3 focuses on CCO topics.
tip: check both to keep informed!

Communiques

Pre-Dating & Back-Dating are Equally Risky

The SEC today suspended three accountants formerly of BDO USA LLP for improper professional conduct during its 2013 audit of AmTrust Financial Services Inc., an exchange-listed insurance company. According to the... read more »

Fiduciary Duty

On Friday, September 28, 2018 the SEC charged LendingClub Asset Management (LCA) and its former president Renaud Laplanche with fraud for improperly using fund money to benefit LendingClub Corporation (LendingClub),... read more »

Exciting Summer Project -- Dig Into Some Sand or Dig Into Your Firm's Best Ex Pr…

The Office of Compliance Inspections and Examinations (OCIE) issued a risk alert July 11 targeting investment advisers’ most common deficiencies with regard to their best execution obligations under the Investment... read more »

SEC Adopts Fund Liquidity Reporting and Disclosure Changes

The final week of June was a busy one for SEC releases following the SEC’s June 28th open meeting. Among these was a revisit of Rule 22e-4 under the Investment... read more »

More SEC Settlements - This Time Form PF Filing Deficiencies

On June 1st, the SEC announced settlements with 13 RIAs who repeatedly failed to file Form PF reports. Most of these firms never filed over the review period (2012 through... read more »

Two Recent Enforcement Actions Against Private Fund Advisers

The industry should not misinterpret the SEC’s 2018 National Exam Program Priorities as a shift away from private fund advisers. As discussed during the SEC’s recent National Compliance Outreach Seminar... read more »

Events

Dorsey PF 2018 Symposium

When: September 26, 2018 (8:30 am - 6 pm Where: Dorsey & Whitney LLP | 51 W. 52nd Street | New York, NY 10019 Directions > SEC3’s President, Janaya Moscony will join...

Chief Compliance Officer Roundtable: Breakfast Briefing - June 14, 2018

When: June 14, 2018 Where: Blank Rome LLP | The Chrysler Building | 405 Lexington Avenue | New York, NY 10174 | 22nd Floor Boardroom | Phone: 212.885.5000 Schedule: 9:00-9:30am - Networking...

Webinar: 2018 SEC Exam Priorities & Recent Exam Highlights

Don’t miss the opportunity to meet with us in person to discuss the topics that matter most to you. Tobin S. Cochran, Managing Member/President of Focus 1 Associates, LLC and...

Chief Compliance Officer Roundtable: Breakfast Briefing - February 7, 2018

When: February 7, 2018 Where: Blank Rome LLP | The Chrysler Building | 405 Lexington Avenue | New York, NY 10174 | 22nd Floor Boardroom | Phone: 212.885.5000 Schedule: 9:00-9:30am - Networking...

Upcoming Events - September & October 2017

Upcoming Events Don’t miss the opportunity to meet with us in person to discuss the topics that matter most to you. SEC3 is teaming up with industry experts in NYC to discuss...

May 23, 2017 - Webcast: WannaCry Ransomware: Were You Really Protected or Just L…

When: Tuesday, May 23rd, 2017 | Schedule: 12pm - 1pm EST Who: Paul Caiazzo, CEO and Co-Founder, TruShield Security Solutions Michael Brice, Founder, BW Cyber Services John Lukan, Managing Director, SEC Compliance Consultants, Inc. We...

June 14, 2017 - Compliance Breakfast Briefing

8:30-9:00am - Networking and Continental Breakfast 9:00-10:30am - Program Location: Willkie Farr & Gallagher LLP | 600 Travis Street | Suite 2310 | Houston, TX Barry Barbash from Willkie Farr & Gallagher LLP,...

June 13, 2017 - Compliance Breakfast Briefing

8:30-9:00am - Networking and Continental Breakfast 9:00-10:30am - Program Location: Haynes and Boone, LLP | 2323 Victory Avenue | Suite 700 | Dallas, TX 75219 Validated parking is available in the garage attached...

May 31, 2017 - Chicago

9:00-9:30 a.m - Networking and Continental Breakfast 9:30-11:00 a.m - Program Location: Baker & McKenzie LLP | 300 East Randolph Drive | Suite 5000 | Chicago, IL 60601 Kristin Gonzalez and Jerome Tomas...

May 17, 2017 (NYC WIMF)

This event is by invitation only. Please email info@seccc.com to learn more.

May 15, 2017 (NYC Chief Compliance Officer Roundtable)

9:00-9:30am - Networking and Continental Breakfast 9:30-11:00am - Program Location: Blank Rome LLP | The Chrysler Building | 405 Lexington Avenue | New York, NY 10174 | 22nd Floor Boardroom | Phone:...

Webcast: The Most Insidious Cybersecurity Threat Is Also The Least Understood

When: Tuesday, April 25th | Schedule: 12pm - 1pm EST Who: Paul Caiazzo, CEO and Co-Founder, TruShield Security Solutions Michael Brice, Founder, BW Cyber Services John Lukan, Managing Director, SEC Compliance Consultants, Inc. Ransomware, the...

CCO Liability (Part III): Managing Liability Webinar

In this webinar, panelists discuss indemnifications and insurance as potential remedies to address the direct financial risks to a CCO. Attendees will learn: What terms and conditions should Chief Compliance Officers be...

Webinar: CCO Liability (Part III): Managing Liability: Navigating Indemnities an…

When: Tuesday, February 21, 2017 Schedule: 11:00am ET / 10:00am CT / 9:00am MT / 8:00am PT / 7:00am AT Description of Webinar: The National Society of Compliance Professionals is pleased to host...

Webcast: SEC 2017 Examination Focus Area – Cybersecurity Testing

Penetration Testing & Vulnerability Assessments - Examining the SEC & FINRA Requirements When: Wednesday, January 25th | Schedule: 12pm - 1pm EST Who: Paul Caiazzo, CEO and Co-Founder, TruShield Security Solutions Michael Brice, Founder,...